Bhrigu's question

कभी जो याद भी आता हूँ मैं तो कहते हैं के आज बज़्म में कुछ फ़ित्ना-ओ-फ़साद नहीं - मिर्ज़ा ग़ालिब

Name:
Location: the valley, California, United States

Bay Area, Strategy Manager, Haas- U. C. Berkeley, Marathons

Friday, June 16, 2006

Dalyrmple reviews a book

Theodore Dalrymple reviews 'Islamic Imperialism - a history' by Efraim Kersh.
The originality of Karsh’s interpretation is its underlying assumption that Islam was, from the very beginning, a pretext for personal and dynastic political ambition, from the razzias against the Meccan caravans and the expulsion of Jewish tribes from Medina, to the siege of Vienna a millennium later in 1529, and Hamas today.
and

Karsh argues [..] Islam has never succeeded in eliminating political power struggles within the Muslim world, where, on the contrary, such struggles have always been murderous. Islamic regimes, many espousing in the beginning the ascetic principles of what one might call desert Islam, invariably degenerate (if it be degeneration) into luxury- and privilege-loving dynasties. Like all other political entities, Islamic regimes seek to preserve and, if possible, extend their power.

Indeed. While, the portrayal by Edward Said and others of a colonised Arabia reflects history of a recent vintage. For too long, Asia and Africa were under the yoke of Arabic imperialism. The victims of this imperialism, most notably, India, Persia and Egypt have had lasting damage done to them. The collapse of it has left a legacy of craving in much of the elite living in Arabic nations. They practice what Kanan Makiya labelled as 'the politics of rejection - reject, reject, reject'.

2 Comments:

Blogger Old Spice said...

No fair - I saw Dalrymple, and thought you were talking about the more acomplished William. (And I think there may be a typo in the header.)

I like to think that Islam is the way it is because it's at the same stage now that Christianity was at during the crusades - the enlightenment hasn't yet come, so problems do. Any alternative explanation is just too scary.

7:06 PM  
Blogger Quizman said...

graduate: LOL. I've corrected the spelling.

Well, even Christianity in the post-RC era has had its share of territorial ambitions. But the point that I was trying to make was that what the Arabs did was colonisation, plain and simple. I don't know why historians have trouble stating that.

7:39 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home